Hiring an ISA vs. Hiring Live Callers: What Each One Actually Costs

Every agent who has ever thought about hiring an ISA has done the same math in their head: one person, full time, working the phones while I go on appointments. It sounds like the answer. The question is what that person actually costs — and what you get for it versus paying per homeowner called.

What an in-house ISA costs

ZipRecruiter puts the average US real estate ISA at $69,398 a year in base pay — about $5,783 a month — with most ISAs between $50,000 and $86,500 (October 2026). That is salary alone, before payroll taxes, tools, and management time. Fully loaded, published 2026 breakdowns put an in-house ISA at roughly $4,600–$7,100 a month, and $75,000–$85,000 in year one once recruiting, training, and the 90–120 day ramp period are counted.

Then there is the part nobody budgets for: turnover. Published analyses note in-house ISAs frequently leave within 6–12 months, which means the recruiting and ramp cost repeats. A trained ISA past the ramp typically books 3–5 listing appointments a week — 12–20 a month — which works out to roughly $300+ per booked appointment at typical production.

What a virtual ISA / VA costs

The middle option is a remote ISA through a staffing company. MyOutDesk's managed full-time ISA starts at $1,988 a month (8 hours a day, 5 days a week); published 2026 benchmarks put full-time managed offshore VAs at $1,800–$3,500 a month, and lighter virtual ISA services from around $720 a month for part-time coverage. Cheaper than in-house, but it is still a monthly retainer: you pay it whether the phones were busy or not, and you still manage, train, and replace the person.

What live callers cost

Circle Prospecting charges $0.50 per homeowner called, with no contract. There is no salary, no ramp, no turnover to manage — you pay for the homes around a listing, and the callers work them.

One real example, from a Wesley Chapel listing: 1,235 homeowners around the listing, $617.50 total, 128 connected conversations, 19 leads (9 of them sellers). That is one campaign, one listing, one bill — about a tenth of one month of an in-house ISA's base pay, for a defined result you can measure.

The honest comparison is not "ISA bad, callers good." An ISA you keep for years, who knows your database and your voice, does work a per-campaign caller does not: nurturing old leads, working your sphere, following up for months. That is the Re-Engage side of the business, and it is real work. The question is whether you need a full-time salary to get the calling done — or whether you need the calls done, around the listings you have this week.

The decision, in one line

If you have listings going live and need the homes around them called now, pay per homeowner and measure the result. If you have a database that needs daily nurture for a year, that is when a full-time ISA — or a virtual one — starts to earn its retainer.

If you have a listing going live in Florida or Georgia and want the homes around it called this week, that's what Circle Prospecting does — live callers, around your Just Listed and Just Sold listings. Enter your listing at circleprospecting.com/buy-leads to see how many homeowners are around it.

Sources